Paul Fagan

Department English and American Studies
PhD Supervisor Univ.-Prof. Dr. Werner Huber (University of Vienna)
Start Summer semester 2010 (University of Vienna)
Contact paul.fagan@sbg.ac.at
Topic/Title Spectacles of Blindness and Insight: 'The Great Hoax' from Swift to Beckett

Abstract

In the introduction to his 1894 compendium of The Humour of Ireland, David James O'Donoghue specifies that in forging a canon of Irish comic writing he will leave aside "the anonymous, the hybrid, the spurious" (xvii). This doctoral thesis demonstrates that the discursive event of the literary hoax, that polyphonic site of "the anonymous, the hybrid, the spurious," is inextricable from the canon that O'Donoghue proposes to formulate. It is argued that the interface between literary hoaxes and more standard forms of fiction constitutes a critically under-theorised dimension of the Irish canon. By reclaiming the importance of hoaxes on the margins of dominant discourses – in astrological almanacs, travelogues, scientific reports, pamphlets, essays, translations, newspaper articles, confessions, critical tracts, scholarly lectures, and various genres ostensibly marked with tags such as 'non-fiction', 'referential', 'trustworthy', 'true' – this study imbues undifferentiated essentialist readings of the Irish tradition with historical depth. More significantly, it demonstrates the extent to which the project of staging and deconstructing the problem of trust in the literary event is a central drive of Irish comic writing.
The study covers a broad historical and generic spectrum of ad hoc engagements with the cultural logics and literary devices of the hoax: preparing falsified documents, forging signatures, and manipulating the truth-claims encoded in discursive genres so as to claim spuriously and then challenge an authority grounded in expertise, insight, and a necessary trust. Authors considered from this perspective include Jonathan Swift ("The Bickerstaff Affair", Gulliver's Travels), Maria Edgeworth (An Essay on Irish Bulls), William Maginn (Fraser's Magazine for Town and Country), Francis Sylvester Mahony ("The Prout Papers"), James Clarence Mangan (Anthologica Germanica, Literæ Orientales), Sheridan Le Fanu ("The Room at the Dragon Volant"), Brian O'Nolan (The Irish Times Letters Hoax, The Third Policeman), James Joyce (Finnegans Wake), and Samuel Beckett ("Le Concentrisme," Ohio Impromptu). In its broader thesis, the study considers how the (perhaps uncomfortably close) relationship between the literary hoax and the fictional text compels us to turn away from a model of analysing literature along an axis of truth and falsehood – as a series of propositional 'truth claims' about the world – to one that considers literature and its various responses in print as an intersubjective event in which texts play with the perlocutionary forces of belief, expectation, and trust. In its narrower thesis, the project considers how the hoax's various hijackings and transgressions of the law of genre, the authenticating gestures of paratextual and exegetical apparatuses, and the authority of the signature are (and perhaps cannot help but be) concomitant with challenges to the normative discourses of expertise, authenticity, and taste. In the process they test Steven Shapin's claim that "the identification of trustworthy agents is necessary to the constitution of any body of knowledge" and expose the ideological abuses of a trust which is, perforce, "reposed in morally bound truth-tellers and promise-keepers". While each text analysed conceptualises differently the co-ordinates of authentic and inauthentic knowledge and the sources of deception in their cultural moment, they all share the attempt to claim (spuriously) and then challenge the expertise, authority, and right to speak the truth and command the reader's trust.
This PhD project's primary goals are intimately related to a number of overlapping strands of the ARGE Kulturelle Dynamiken research clusters, in particular hybridisation (in the hoax's dual status as a strict adherence to and subversive transgression of the laws of genre), transmedialisation, (in the hoax's tendency both to call on the authority of multiple media forms to bolster its claims to authenticity and to incorporate responses in various media into its ever-proliferating forms), theatricalisation (in the hoax's explorations of the power of performativity, simulation, and the fake to alter and shape reality), and memorialisation (in its sustained engagement with the "problem of the archive"; exploiting the fact that barring omniscience, at some point we all must place our trust in the claims of others who have travelled to the archive and returned with word of its contents or else devolve into paranoid scepticism).

  • News
    The Paris Lodron University of Salzburg has launched an in-house mentoring program for new students as part of the “On Track” project. And it has come at the right time, because the lockdown has made the start of their studies into a real challenge for many first-semester students.
    18 participants recently completed the university course in early childhood education with a master's degree. The course was held for the second time in Salzburg. Regional Minister Andrea Klambauer awarded prizes to nine of the graduates for their outstanding theses.
    The recording of the PLUS Talks "Studies and Teaching WS 2020/21“ from 25.11.2020 is now available.
    Matthias Henke, musicologist, Danube University Krems, talks about Beethoven's current biography “Beethoven. Akkord der Welt ( Chord of the World)”, published in 2020 by Hanser Verlag.
    24 very easy exercises on 24 cards can be found in the SALTO advent calendar. The exercise ideas are ideal for children from the age of three and are also easy for the whole family to carry out in a small space. With the support of the Kinder Büro (Children's Office), this combinable contribution should benefit as many as possible.
    Researchers led by Salzburg's geoinformatics scientist Christian Neuwirth had already developed and presented a mathematical model for Covid-19 in May 2020 which examines the question of how long and intensively social distancing measures have to be maintained in order to reduce corona deaths further.
    Results of the study on media use by children and families during lockdown. Home schooling could be improved, but is on the right track. Secondary schools have a better profile. Families have learned to deal with lockdown and homeschooling.
    As a result of the current situation the updated opening times for Salzburg University library will apply from the 17th November 2020.
    A study carried out by the sleep laboratory of the Faculty of Natural Sciences on the topic of sleep under the direction Prof. Dr. Manuel Schabus is dedicated to the changes in sleep during the Covid-19 lockdown in 6 different countries (Ö, AT, UK, GR, CU, BRA). The fear, which is worrying from a psychological point of view, and which is evident across society, is also reflected in this data: 78% of those surveyed feel threatened or worried by the Covid-19 pandemic.
    Online lecture on chemistry: December 2nd 2020 - 6 p.m. Emmanuelle Charpentier and Jennifer Doudna received the 2020 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for the discovery of one of the sharpest tools in genetic engineering: the CRISPR / Cas9 genetic scissors. With this technology, researchers can modify the DNA of animals, plants and microorganisms with extremely high precision.
    The PLUS Report 2020 has been published.
    Digitization has led to an enormous spread of different forms of mobile working. Corona has brought an additional boost and has introduced home office in areas and for activities that were previously unimaginable.
    During the time of Corona, in particular, it became clear just how important it is to support students digitally in their every day university life. The project „On Track“ – stay on track combines digital and social worlds. It is starting at the right time!
  • Veranstaltungen
  • 01.12.20 „Geflügelte Worte“
    01.12.20 Der Körper als PLAYFUL TOOL
    02.12.20 „Geflügelte Worte“
    02.12.20 PLUS startupSPRECHTAG - gather your ideas
    02.12.20 Musikpyhsiologie und Musikermedizin: Musizieren im Zusammenwirken von Psyche und Körper
    02.12.20 Nobelpreise 2020 - CHEMIE (Genschere)
    03.12.20 „Geflügelte Worte“
    04.12.20 „Geflügelte Worte“
    04.12.20 Ideen mit Methode
    05.12.20 „Geflügelte Worte“
    06.12.20 „Geflügelte Worte“
  • Alumni Club
  • PRESS
  • University of Salzburg's facebook site University of Salzburg's twitter site University of Salzburg's instagram site University of Salzburg's flickr site University of Salzburg's vimeo site