Hamid Taieb

Relatives and intentionality in Brentano?s last texts

In this paper, I will analyse the last texts of Brentano about the relational aspect of intentionality. I will show that Brentano goes more and more in the direction of a theory in which intentionality is a non-reducible real relative occurring even without an existing correlative. In other words, at the end of his life, intentionality becomes for Brentano what scholars call a “one-sided relation” (J. Haldane) or a “non-extensional relation” (R. M. Chisholm, A. Chrudzimski). To show this, I will use two series of manuscripts from the Nachlass. A first series is composed of unpublished texts, which are useful in understanding Brentano’s evolution concerning relatives and intentionality. A second series is composed of published texts used by A. Kastil in editing the Kategorienlehre. I will show that A. Kastil’s edition is not always faithful to the manuscripts. All the texts from the Kategorienlehre that I will use to support my argument will be compared to the sources in the Nachlass. A large number of scholars admit that Brentano’s last theory of intentionality is not a relational but an adverbial theory. The main source of this interpretation is a well-known text of 1911, in the Appendix to the re-edition of his Psychology, where Brentano says that intentionality is not a relative, but something relative-like (relativlich). Thus, since R. M. Chisholm, interpreters consider that Brentano has reduced, from an ontological point of view, the relational aspect of intentionality to absolute features of the subject, even if he maintained a relational « grammar » for intentionality (A. Chrudzimski, B. Smith). Nevertheless, it seems to me that interpreters provide no text where Brentano explicitly affirms the reduction of the intentional relative to absolute features. I will present a difficult text of 1908, unpublished, where Brentano discusses the interactions between the intentional relative and the absolute features of the subject. Regardless of this text, surely Brentano had an ontologically non-relational theory of intentionality in 1911, as he affirms it himself in the Appendix. However, I believe that things changed in 1915-1916. Indeed, in 1911, the reason for rejecting the relational aspect of intentionality was the absence of a correlative for some acts of thinking (some acts are directed upon non-existing objects, and no mind-dependent correlative can replace these missing objects). As we know, Brentano refused the existence of one-sided relatives in 1911. On the contrary, in 1915-1916, one-sided relatives are admitted: a relative exists even without an existing correlative. By the way, the relatives that were opposed in 1911 to the intentional act as being relatives having existing correlatives, namely the causal and the comparative relatives, will also become one-sided in 1915 (Brentano himself, in an unpublished text of 1915, uses the adjective “einseitig”). Thus, there is a reversal in Brentano’s ontology of relatives. I will show that the main text of the Kategorienlehre that establishes this reversal is a production of A. Kastil, who combined two different manuscripts. It is useful to emend this text, since scholars frequently quote it (L. Gilson, B. Smith, A. Chrudzimski, W. Sauer, M. Antonelli). Despite this emendation, the reversal can be proved.

Of course, one could object that this reversal does not imply that Brentano admits real one-sided relatives. One counterargument could be that Brentano generally reduces relatives to absolute features of their bearers (A. Chrudzimski); thus, the one-sided intentional relative cannot be real in the final analysis. This position seems to me to be questionable. I will show that there are many texts where Brentano says that relatives are as real as absolute entities. In fact, I think that Brentano increasingly affirms the reality of relatives. In an unpublished text of 1915, he considers that relatives are real, but reducible to the categories of the absolute accidents upon which they are founded. So, they do not form a proper category of accidents. But in 1916, in a text published in the Kategorienlehre, he affirms that relatives do form a proper category of accidents. Thus, the general reduction of relatives seems to be difficult to defend. Another argument against my reading could be that even if there is an increasing acceptance of the reality of relatives, this increase does not concern one-sided relatives, which can all be reduced to absolute features, even in 1916. I think that there are two reasons to reject this counterargument. First, Brentano, when he affirms in 1916 that relatives form a proper category of accidents, does not say that the category is limited to two-sided relatives. Second, in a text of 1916 published in the Kategorienlehre, Brentano gives the following list of relatives, containing mainly one-sided ones: categorial, causal, boundary, intentional and comparative relatives. Then, he says that the last class, the one of comparative relatives, is reducible to absolute properties of the bearer. Thus, by contrast, it is not the case for the other classes of relatives, including the intentional relative. Since in 1916 one-sided relatives are admitted, since they are real, since they are members of a proper accidental category and since only the comparative relatives are reducible to absolute features of their bearer, it becomes hard to explain how the intentional one-sided relative could be something else than a non-reducible real relative. I will provide criticism of this theory of intentionality.

  • ENGLISH English
  • News
    Die MMG –Gruppe (spezialisiert auf Migrations- und Mobilitätsforschung) wurde von der neuen Professorin für „Mobilität und sozialer Wandel“ der Abteilung Soziologie, Fachbereich Politikwissenschaft und Soziologie, Kyoko Shinozaki ins Leben gerufen und ist dem wichtigsten internationalen Netzwerk für Migrationsforschung (IMISCOE, https://www.imiscoe.org/) nun beigetreten.
    Im Rahmen der Vortragsreihe POLEMIK UND GENDER wird Ulrike Vedder vom Institut für deutsche Literatur der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin am 14. November um 19h einen Gastvortrag im Unikpark Nonntal halten. // Erzabt-Klotz-Str. 1, E.002 (Agnes Muthspiel) // www.w-k.sbg.ac.at/de/kunstpolemik-polemikkunst
    Vortrag von Anne Vogelpohl am Mittwoch, 14. November 2018, 18 Uhr im HS 436, 3. Stock der Naturwissenschaftlichen Fakultät, Hellbrunnerstraße 34
    Beim eMobilitätstag am 14. November 2018 am Vorplatz Unipark Nonntal in Kooperation mit der Fa. Frey besteht die Möglichkeit sich zu informieren und auch ein eAuto zu testen.
    Am: 15.11.2018 // Zeit: 18:30h s.t. - 20:00h // Ort: Hörsaal 207 der Rechtswiss. Fakultät der Universität Salzburg // Churfürststraße 1 // A-5020 Salzburg // (Zugang beschildert)
    Die neunte Tagung der "Salzburger interdisziplinären Diskurse" zum Thema "Kommunikation und Medien zwischen Kulturindustrie, Lebenswelt und Politik" findet am 15./16. November 2018 im Europasaal der Edmundsburg (Mönchsberg 2, Salzburg) statt.
    Tagung zu Übersetzung und Polemik im KunstQuartier // Donnerstag, 15. November, 18:30h ABENDVORTRAG: ULRICH WYSS (Frankfurt am Main): Übersetzen als Polemik – Borchardts Dante // Bergstr. 12a, 1. OG, W&K-Atelier // www.w-k.sbg.ac.at/de/kunstpolemik-polemikkunst
    Rudolf Krska hält am 16. November 2018 um 11:30 Uhr im HS 421 der NW-Fakultät einen Gastvortrag zum Thema "Novel (Integrated) Methods to Control, Detect and Reduce Mycotoxins in Food and Feed". Der Fachbereich Biowissenschaften lädt herzlich dazu ein!
    Florian P. Schiestll hält am 16. November 2018 um 14:00 Uhr im HS 435 der NW-Fakultät einen Gastvortrag zum Thema "Divergent floral evolution driven by pollinators and herbivores". Der Fachbereich Biowissenschaften lädt herzlich dazu ein!
    Es ist wieder so weit, am 17. November 2018 findet das Konzert des Universitätsorchesters für dieses Semester statt.
    Der Fachbereich Psychologie lädt am 17.11.18 zum Fest-Symposium zur 20-jährigen Kooperation der Stadt Salzburg, Senioreneinrichtungen, und der Universität Salzburg, Fachbereich Psychologie, ein.
    Mo. 19.11.2018, 17.15 Uhr, HS E.001 (Unipark) - ao. Univ.-Prof. Dr. Agnethe Siquans (Wien) - Kirchenväter und Judentum
    Herr Dr. Sven Th. Schipporeit (Institut für Klassische Archäologie, Universität Wien) hält zu diesem Thema am Mi, 21. November 2018, 18.30 Uhr, in der Abgusssammlungs SR E.33, Residenzplatz 1, einen Vortrag
    Sebastian Meyer hält am 23. November 2018 um 14:00 Uhr im HS 436 der NW-Fakultät einen Gastvortrag zum Thema "Biodiversity-ecosystem functioning relationships and their drivers in natural and anthropogenic systems with an emphasis on species interactions". Der Fachbereich Biowissenschaften lödt herzlich dazu ein!
    The workshop aims to examine the musicality of the body and vice versa the corporeality of music from a choreographic perspective. This approach corresponds with the extension of the concept of music as well as the questioning of performance traditions in the context of New Music, which also puts a stronger emphasis on the body.
    The relatively young democracy Poland, whose political climate has intensified considerably since the last elections, is also moving increasingly to the fore. Politically critical leaders of representative cultural organisations have been and continue to be replaced by the new administration, while independent creative artists appear to be able to find niches so far or already live outside the country.
    Vom 29.11. bis 01.12.2018 im Unipark Nonntal
    Das Symposion der Katholische-Theologischen Fakultät findet am 29. und 30. November anlässlich der Aufhebung im Jahre 1938 statt. Veranstaltungsort ist der Hörsaal 101 der Theologischen Fakultät, Universitätsplatz 1.
    Salzburger Innovationstagung 2018 am 29.11.2018 ab 15 Uhr in der Großen Universitätsaula – ITG, Land Salzburg, Wirtschaftskammer und Salzburger Hochschulkonferenz
    Am 30. November im Rahmen der Tagung Digital Humanities Austria 2018
    Am 6. Dezember 2018 finden an der Universität Salzburg die WTZ Training Days zum Thema Kommunikation, Dissemination und Verbreitung in H2020-Projekten statt.
  • Veranstaltungen
  • 14.11.18 Geschlechterforschung und Gegenwartsliteratur: Zur kritischen Reflexion von Polemik
    15.11.18 Übersetzung und Polemik
    15.11.18 Vorträge der Salzburger Juristischen Gesellschaft
    16.11.18 Übersetzung und Polemik
    16.11.18 "Probleme des Vorsteuerabzuges mit Schwerpunkt Umsatzsteuerbetrug"
    17.11.18 "Probleme des Vorsteuerabzuges mit Schwerpunkt Umsatzsteuerbetrug"
    17.11.18 Übersetzung und Polemik
    17.11.18 Konzert des Universitätsorchesters Salzburg
    19.11.18 Medeas furor: Christliche Mythenkritik in Dracontius' Romulea?
  • Alumni Club
  • PRESSE
  • Uni-Shop
  • VERANSTALTUNGSRÄUME
  • STELLENMARKT
  • Facebook-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg Twitter-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg Instagram-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg Flickr-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg Vimeo-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg