Hynek Janousek

Was Husserl right?

Even though Husserl criticized Brentano´s version of descriptive psychology as it is represented in Brentano´s Psychology from the Empirical Standpoint the strongest critique of this version of Brentano´s psychology can be perhaps drawn from Husserl´s second logical investigation in which he rejects theories of abstractions based in different versions of nominalism and conceptualism. Brentano started his philosophical development with a theory of abstraction which was inspired by a conceptualistic branch of Aristotelian theories of abstraction spread in the late scholastic philosophies and by the cartesian version of conceptualism defended by Antoine Arnauld in his Port-Royal Logic. According to both positions we can gain a general concept by looking away from individual determinations of a concrete presentation. Not only Husserl shows that shifts of attention can never lead to a general concept he also wants to show that we cannot accept unity of extension of a general concept without accepting some species as its objective correlate shared by all individuals falling under the general concept. This means that according to Husserl we also need to accept different objective species of intentional acts if we are to talk about their different kinds. This naturally leads to a question about Husserl´s own theory of abstraction which seems to open doors for old problems of platonism. Brentano did not hesitate to point these problems out. A similar set of problems arises when we want to talk about the identity of an intentional object. Husserl seems to accept as obvious that we can intend one and the same object in the same way (it doesn´t matter what further specific determinations regarding its individuality or generality we give) in many different acts of presentations. But what makes this shared identity possible? Either we will try to reduce this kind of identity to some kind of relations of similarity and we will have to face a strong critique made by Husserl against this position or we will accept some kind of ideal contents (as Husserl did) but then we will have to explain platonic problems concerning the participation of the multitude of acts on the one shared content. I would like to present Husserl´s critique of the aboved mentioned version of Brentano´s position and Brentano´s critique of Husserl´s solutions together with the historical background they drew their theories from. I think that every cartesian theory of human mind still needs to face these problems. I would also like to ask if Brentano´s later theory according to which every presentation is general is in a better position to answer poblems connected with Brentano´s early theory of abstraction.

  • ENGLISH English
  • News
    Das Wissen für morgen schon heute erleben – mit diesem Ziel erarbeiten universitäre und außeruniversitäre Forschungseinrichtungen in der Science City Itzling neue Vermittlungsformate.
    Tagung zu Übersetzung und Polemik im KunstQuartier // Donnerstag, 15. November, 18:30h ABENDVORTRAG: ULRICH WYSS (Frankfurt am Main): Übersetzen als Polemik – Borchardts Dante // Bergstr. 12a, 1. OG, W&K-Atelier // www.w-k.sbg.ac.at/de/kunstpolemik-polemikkunst
    Es ist wieder so weit, am 17. November 2018 findet das Konzert des Universitätsorchesters für dieses Semester statt.
    Der Fachbereich Psychologie lädt am 17.11.18 zum Fest-Symposium zur 20-jährigen Kooperation der Stadt Salzburg, Senioreneinrichtungen, und der Universität Salzburg, Fachbereich Psychologie, ein.
    Mo. 19.11.2018, 17.15 Uhr, HS E.001 (Unipark) - ao. Univ.-Prof. Dr. Agnethe Siquans (Wien) - Kirchenväter und Judentum
    Herr Dr. Sven Th. Schipporeit (Institut für Klassische Archäologie, Universität Wien) hält zu diesem Thema am Mi, 21. November 2018, 18.30 Uhr, in der Abgusssammlungs SR E.33, Residenzplatz 1, einen Vortrag
    Vortrag von Prof. Dr. Samuel Mössner, WWU Münster, am Mittwoch, 21.11.2018 um 18h im HS 436, Naturwissenschaftliche Fakultät
    Sebastian Meyer hält am 23. November 2018 um 14:00 Uhr im HS 436 der NW-Fakultät einen Gastvortrag zum Thema "Biodiversity-ecosystem functioning relationships and their drivers in natural and anthropogenic systems with an emphasis on species interactions". Der Fachbereich Biowissenschaften lödt herzlich dazu ein!
    The workshop aims to examine the musicality of the body and vice versa the corporeality of music from a choreographic perspective. This approach corresponds with the extension of the concept of music as well as the questioning of performance traditions in the context of New Music, which also puts a stronger emphasis on the body.
    The relatively young democracy Poland, whose political climate has intensified considerably since the last elections, is also moving increasingly to the fore. Politically critical leaders of representative cultural organisations have been and continue to be replaced by the new administration, while independent creative artists appear to be able to find niches so far or already live outside the country.
    Vom 29.11. bis 01.12.2018 im Unipark Nonntal
    Salzburger Innovationstagung 2018 am 29.11.2018 ab 15 Uhr in der Großen Universitätsaula – ITG, Land Salzburg, Wirtschaftskammer und Salzburger Hochschulkonferenz
    Das Symposion der Katholische-Theologischen Fakultät findet am 29. und 30. November anlässlich der Aufhebung im Jahre 1938 statt. Veranstaltungsort ist der Hörsaal 101 der Theologischen Fakultät, Universitätsplatz 1.
    Am 30. November im Rahmen der Tagung Digital Humanities Austria 2018
    Am 6. Dezember 2018 finden an der Universität Salzburg die WTZ Training Days zum Thema Kommunikation, Dissemination und Verbreitung in H2020-Projekten statt.
  • Veranstaltungen
  • 17.11.18 "Probleme des Vorsteuerabzuges mit Schwerpunkt Umsatzsteuerbetrug"
    17.11.18 Übersetzung und Polemik
    17.11.18 Konzert des Universitätsorchesters Salzburg
    19.11.18 Medeas furor: Christliche Mythenkritik in Dracontius' Romulea?
    21.11.18 Zeit und Kult in der Gründungsphase der neuen Polis Rhodos
    22.11.18 Affine vs. Euclidean isoperimetric inequalities
  • Alumni Club
  • Uni-Shop
  • Facebook-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg Twitter-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg Instagram-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg Flickr-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg Vimeo-Auftritt der Universität Salzburg